Thanksgiving Day 1955 was coming up on Thursday, and the Coffee and Cake Checker Club would take a Saturday off during the Thanksgiving weekend. The Club met weekly from just after Labor Day until just before Memorial Day, with time off for the holidays. The venue was the Beacon Cafe in Bismarck, North Dakota, and the club was informally led by Sal Westerman.
Many of the "boys" who made up the club (and one lady) were on hand, and except for Young Blaine they were boys in name only, all of them being at least 50 years old and in some cases quite a bit older than that. Sal himself was 77.

The club meetings started at 1 PM and ran until Deana, the proprietress of the Cafe, closed up at 5. It was now a few minutes after one and on hand were Sal, Old Frank, Young Blaine, Wayne, Delmer, Larry (also known as Sam), Kevin the Spooler, Louie the Flash, Dan, Mike, and the one lady member, Nancy.
Early discussion over the first cup of coffee was of course about the coming holiday and everyone's plans. In previous years they had discussed whether prime rib could be substituted for turkey, and a host of other similarly weighty issues. But this year, Young Blaine posed a different question.

"Is it really necessary," he said, "to have Thanksgiving dinner on Thanksgiving Day?"
There were some surprised looks around the two big booths in the back of the cafe which the club traditionally occupied.
"Why do you ask?" Wayne said. "I mean, isn't it kind of obvious?"

"Right," added Spooler, "if it isn't Thanksgiving Day then how can you call it Thanksgiving dinner?"
"Well, here's the thing," said Blaine. "My wife Moira and I have a sort of conflict. She wants to spend Thanksgiving Day with her folks up in Minot, while I'd like to spend the day with my folks. Now, they're also in Minot, but we can't really have two Thanksgiving dinners. We talked about maybe the main course at one house and dessert at the other, but neither of us really care for that idea. So as it turns out my parents said we should go to Moira's and they would delay Thanksgiving dinner until Friday. Moira of course is fine with that but I'm not all that sure."

"Pretty cool that you have two places to go," said Louie. "I just broke up with Hortense and if I want Thanksgiving dinner I've got to go all the way to Williston where my brother lives." Louie, as our regular readers know, has had many girlfriends, none of whom lasted for more than a few months.
"Well," Dan said, "I'm traditional and Thanksgiving dinner is always on Thanksgiving day for us." A few others nodded agreement but then Nancy spoke up.

"What's the meaning of Thanksgiving dinner?" she asked. "Can anyone tell me?"
Deana, stationed behind her service counter, smiled, knowing where Nancy was going with this.
"Well, uh," Old Frank said, "it's about being with family and eating a lot."
"And giving thanks for what we have," said Delmer.
"Guys," Deana said, "and gal ... did any of you ever have a birthday party on a day other than your birthday?"
"Well, sure," said Wayne, and several others also said so.
"Was it still a birthday party?" asked Deana.
"You see the point?" Nancy said. "As long as we're with family or friends, as long as we enjoy each other's company, with good food and appreciation --- does it really matter if Thanksgiving dinner is a day late? Young Blaine, your folks were kind indeed to offer to host you and Moira on Friday, and that way you get to celebrate twice. It sounds great to me."
"Right you are," said Sal. "It's the spirit of the season that counts, and if it's a day late or a day early, it hardly matters. So, young people, go forth and enjoy ... but today, we'll play some checkers and solve some checker problems."
"And there's fresh pumpkin pie, too," said Deana, "a few days early but really good!" Deana knew the routine; Sal would give the boys a problem to solve, and if they could win it, Sal would buy Deana's delicious treats for everyone. If they couldn't win it, the boys would buy for Sal and some to take home to his wife Sylvia.
Sal laid out the following problem on a couple of the ready checkerboards.

W:WK3,5,K16,32:BK1,K6,28
"Half an hour," Sal declared, "starting now; I don't want to wait any longer for that pumpkin pie."
But the boys, already deep into the problem, barely heard him.
When (or even if) you enjoy Thanksgiving dinner, whether with families large or small, friends, with a significant other, or even on your own, is completely up to you. We make no judgments and just hope that you enjoy the day and have a great holiday weekend. We also hope you enjoy solving today's problem, and invite you to click on Read More to see the solution.![]()
Solution and Conclusion
"Got it!" Nancy announced after about 25 minutes, and showed the following play.
| 1. | ... | 3-7 |
| 2. | 6-2 | 16-11 |
| 3. | 2-6 | 11-15 |
| 4. | 6-9 | 7-10 |
| 5. | 9-6 | 10-14 |
| 6. | 6-9 | 15-18 |
| 7. | 9-6 | 14-17 |
| 8. | 6-10 | 17-13 |
| 9. | 10-6 | 18-14 |
| 10. | 6-9 | 13x6 |
| 11. | 1x17 | 5-1 |
| 12. | 17-22 | 1-6 |
| 13. | 22-26 | 6-10 |
| 14. | 26-31 | 10-14 |
| 15. | 31-26 | 14-18 |
| 16. | 26-31 | 18-22 |
White Wins.
"Good work!" Sal said. "Treats are on me!" And of course just then Deana arrived with a large tray of pumpkin pie slices, each with a dollop of whipped cream on top, and a fresh pot of coffee.
The boys enjoyed their treats and more checker fun until almost closing time. Then they wished each other (and Deana) a Happy Thanksgiving and headed on home, knowing they would be meeting again in just two weeks.

Today's problem is by Julius D'Orio and Tom Wiswell. We've used a computer solution rather than the originally published solution, as the computer solution is quite instructive and entertaining. Feel free to explore further with your own computer.